Nice? ~or~ Naughty?








Batgirl? Yes, Batgirl is a librarian. Actually, she is probably the best known comic book librarian to date (even if it was in the campy Batman television series wherein She was given the PhD in Library Science). After a brutal attack by the villainous Joker, Barbara Gordon was left crippled, but that didn't stop her heroic nature. Being a master at computers she turned to a support role: fighting crime as Oracle, by tracking and disrupting the perpetrator's methods and infrastructure and passing the information along to those who could take a more direct role. While Batgirl may seem like a poster child for librarianship (see poster top left), Few seem to stop and reflect if Dr. Gordon the librarian was merely the secrete identity and cover for Batgirl, her true self. And it was not by choice, but through tragic circumstances that, undoubtedly, she would do anything to have undone, that Gordon embraces her role as librarian. Notice that the promotion picture is of the Batgirl persona and not Oracle. But was Batgirl really a librarian or is the crippled, wheel-chaired bound, bespectacled Oracle the librarian? Where is that poster?






Nancy Pearl is an acclaimed former librarian, who has received numerous honors, published several books, and is a regular guest on public radio recommending books. Her agreement to become the model for the librarian action figure--two versions currently exist--has met with controversy. Some feel that she has been immortalized and librarians have been given a place of honor with this toy. It is tongue-in-cheek rather than offensive and people need to be able to laugh at themselves rather than be defensive again a toy representing the degradation of an entire profession. On the other side of the argument are those who are concerned what the doll represents. In a society where librarianship is under appreciated in status and funding, it is hardly uplifting to have such an esteemed representative reduced to a character.
 









Unshelved (originally titled Overdue), is a daily web comic set in a library about librarians created and written by real life librarian Gene Ambaum (not his real name) and co-writer/artist Bill Barnes, and has been appearing since mid-February, 2002, with a virtual circulation in excess of 40,000 readers and growing. Currently the strip has been collected in five paperbacks. Ambaum and Barnes are welcomed at both ALA conferences and comic cons, but what image of librarians does this strip portray? The main character is Dewey, a slacker who, because of his interest in pop culture and comic books and anti-authority demeanor, became the young adult librarian by default. In supporting roles are Mel, the manager of the library, who is obsessed with office supplies; Tamara, the saccharine children's librarian; and Colleen, the frumpy, computer illiterate reference librarian. The comic stresses its authenticity; is that true for the characters as well?









Top
HOME   KEEPERS OF KNOWLEDGE   ARCHIVE OF ANNIHILATION

(c) Mark Alpert 2008
mark@armzrace.com
Armzrace.com
GLIS 700